carnosine gel vs beta alanine
Is carnosine gel just menthol?
No. Seven international rugby sevens players, a placebo with the same menthol, triple-blind — and peak power was still higher on the carnosine gel.
Affiliate links. We earn a commission if you buy — it costs you nothing extra and does not change what we publish.
No. The gel was tested in a 2025 triple-blind trial on seven international rugby sevens players against a placebo with the same 1.25% menthol. Peak power was still higher on the gel — 5–10% in the authors’ summary, significant in three of twelve sprints — while mean power did not change. Same menthol, different peak power, in seven players.
No — and a 2025 trial was built specifically to test it. Researchers gave seven international rugby sevens players two unlabelled bottles: the carnosine gel, and a placebo gel containing the same 1.25% menthol. Both smelled and tingled identically, and nobody — players, testers or analysts — knew which was which. After twelve maximal sprints on each, peak power was higher on the carnosine gel: 1426 W vs 1270 W in sprint 7, 1433 W vs 1332 W in sprint 2, 1347 W vs 1244 W in sprint 4. The authors summarise the gain as 5–10% more peak power. Since the menthol was identical in both bottles, the menthol cannot explain the difference. Mean power did not change, and seven players is a small sample.
Why do people think carnosine gel is just menthol?
Because menthol is real: rub it on a working muscle and it feels cool and different, and a menthol gel compared against nothing will always feel like it did something. So the fair question is whether carnosine gel adds anything beyond the tingle.
The only way to answer that is to put the same menthol in the placebo. That is exactly what the 2025 trial did.

How did the 2025 trial rule menthol out?
It put the same menthol in the placebo: ultrasound gel with 1.25% menthol added, matched to the smell and menthol level of the carnosine gel. Both went into unlabelled bottles, and the person who filled them took no part in running the sessions or crunching the numbers.
- Triple-blind: athletes, testers and analysts all blind until the stats were done.
- Crossover: every athlete did both conditions seven days apart, order counterbalanced.
- Protocol: 12 × (24 s at 3 W/kg, 6 s flat out, 30 s rest), two-minute break after the sixth.
- Independent: run by the University of Waikato, Hong Kong Baptist University and New Zealand Rugby, and published in the peer-reviewed Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition.
What did the carnosine add?
Peak power was higher on the carnosine gel in sprint 2 (1433 W vs 1332 W), sprint 4 (1347 W vs 1244 W) and sprint 7 (1426 W vs 1270 W) — the three of twelve sprints where the gap was statistically significant. Mean power, heart rate and perceived effort did not change. The authors put the overall gain at 5–10% more peak power.
Peak power is the top-end burst inside each 6-second sprint. On the gel it was higher in sprints 2, 4 and 7, and average power across the twelve did not change: a higher top end in some sprints, not more work overall.

So what is the menthol for?
Comfort and feel. Menthol on its own gives a small, mostly perceived cooling effect, mainly in endurance work. The carnosine is what the trial tested: with the menthol matched, peak power across repeated sprints was still 5–10% higher, though how it works is not established. If you would rather skip the tingle, the gel also comes in a menthol-free version, and the best carnosine gels, compared covers the alternatives.
Want the version the trial tested? Apply it 45 minutes before your next hard session, and see the difference for yourself — backed by a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Sources
- Topical carnosine gel improves intermittent high-intensity exercise performance in world-class rugby sevens players (Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2025) (opens in a new tab) PMC12427510
The triple-blind trial whose placebo was matched for 1.25% menthol, and the source of every per-sprint power figure on this page.
- Acute topical menthol application and exercise performance — systematic review and meta-analysis (opens in a new tab) ro.ecu.edu.au
What rub-on menthol does on its own: a small effect, mostly in aerobic endurance and mostly through perceived cooling — a different variable from the peak power the carnosine arm moved.
Performance & Recovery Gel, $55 for with menthol · 100 ml. Informed Sport tested, 30-day money-back guarantee.
Other questions
carnosine gel for horses
Carnosine gel for horses: Fortigo and the absorption study
does carnosine gel work
Does carnosine gel work? What the trials and athletes show
carnosine gel vs carnosport
Carnosine gel vs Carnosport: which one is actually tested?
best carnosine gel
The best carnosine gel in 2026: three options compared
carnosine gel for bjj
Carnosine gel for BJJ: what the trial means for hard rounds
carnosine gel australia
Carnosine gel in Australia: how to get it from the US
carnosine gel side effects
Carnosine gel side effects: what to know before you use it
carnosine gel vs biofreeze
Carnosine gel vs Biofreeze: cooling vs performance
carnosine gel review
Carnosine gel review: does it work, and is it legit?
carnosine gel price
Carnosine gel price: what it really costs per session
carnosine gel vs pr lotion
Carnosine gel vs PR Lotion: carnosine vs bicarbonate
is carnosine gel banned
Is carnosine gel banned? WADA, drug tests and Informed Sport
carnosine gel ingredients
Carnosine gel ingredients: what is in it, menthol vs Original
carnosine gel for cycling
Carnosine gel for cycling: sprints, surges and the evidence
can you absorb carnosine through skin
Can you absorb carnosine through skin? What studies show
carnosine gel vs sportlegs
Carnosine gel vs SportLegs: rub-on carnosine vs lactate capsules
menthol before workout
Menthol before a workout: does it actually help?
why do muscles burn during exercise
Why do muscles burn during exercise? (Not lactic acid)
carnosine benefits
Carnosine Benefits: What Human Studies Actually Show
carnosine gel canada
Carnosine Gel Canada: Where to Buy, Price and Evidence

Try it yourself
Performance & Recovery Gel
Ten pumps a leg, forty-five minutes out. That is the whole method.
10% off your first order through our link · 30-day money-back guarantee
Affiliate links. We earn a commission if you buy — it costs you nothing extra and does not change what we publish.
- Informed SportEvery batch tested
- 30 daysMoney-back guarantee
- 16,500+Athletes, per the brand
- 45 minApply before training
